This just blows my mind.
You’ve probably already read the articles on the reports issued this week on the listeriosis outbreak last summer as a result of tainted Maple Leaf meats. These reports, compiled by Ontario’s Chief Medical Officer of Health, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA), Health Canada and the Public Health Agency of Canada, shows that there was a breakdown in communication between the involved organizations.
This isn’t terribly new news. The confusion surrounding the whole issue last summer made it apparent that no one knew what was going on. It wasn’t until Maple Leaf stepped up and said that they were at fault, they were fixing it, and everything else that they needed to say to repair their public relations, that the public finally understood what was going on. Where was Health Canada? Where was the Public Health Agency? What are we paying these people for?
Anyway, that’s old news. What floored me this morning was the revelation that the CFIA can’t say for sure how many meat inspectors it has.
The CFIA cited a supporting chart showing the number of inspectors now tops 3,000, up from about 1,900 a decade ago. But this includes employees who don’t do meat inspections.
If they have a chart, they must have numbers with which they made the chart, no? Otherwise they’re just making shit up.
The CFIA also blames their data capture for not being able to say for sure how many meat inspectors it has, since some inspectors serve multi-purpose roles. This confuses me. I’ve worked on data capture. Unless their system is completely borked it should be a simple process to pull out how many inspectors filed inspection reports at meat plants.
Wait, it gets better.
Bob Kingston represents CFIA inspectors as the president of the Public Service Alliance of Canada’s agriculture union. He said there are only about 200 “multi-purpose inspectors,” and each one submits monthly expense claims coded to show the amount of time they devote to each commodity program. He suggested the CFIA is “trying to hide” the real number by hiding behind this excuse [regarding data capture].
Kingston estimates that the total number of food inspectors is less than 1,200, excluding trainees and supervisors. Of these, he said about 200 are processed meat inspectors.
Only 200 meat inspectors! Awesome!
So the CFIA went on to clarify their statement because some senators apparently got upset when they said they didn’t know how many inspectors the agency has. (Wonder why?)
The CFIA also clarified that its 3,030 inspectors includes those working in all areas of inspection under the CFIA’s mandate. The number of inspectors working in federally registered meat facilities is approximately 1,400, the agency said. And between March 2006 and March 2008, overall CFIA staff has increased by 13.7 per cent.
Now they have a number? Why didn’t they have it before? And why don’t I trust it?
Ok, that’s the cynic in me. And yes, this article is from March 25. But here’s something else to chew on.
In one of my classes, we were assigned to look for a statement from a spokesperson, and we would be analyzing the statements in class. I decided to look for a statement from a CFIA spokesperson, so I started searching the CBC News site. Here’s what I found:
March 30: “No one from the CFIA was available for an interview.”
March 25: “…CFIA refused to make a spokesperson available to discuss its recall policy.”
March 25: But according to an internal memo obtained by the CBC and Toronto Star…
…etcetera. Pretty much every single “statement” made to the CBC by the CFIA was either in a news release, an emailed statement sent after the reporter called, or in a document obtained via the Freedom of Information Act. Then there’s this:
Canada’s food watchdog is withholding files documenting its handling of the recent nationwide listeria outbreak, citing the high volume of freedom-of-information requests and limited staff resources.
As part of a joint investigation, the CBC and Toronto Star first made requests for the files in August. The files detail meetings between the Canadian Food Inspection Agency, meat processor Maple Leaf Foods Inc. and public health officials. None of the files has been released and the CFIA is seeking extensions that could hold back the release of records for more than a year. Standard extensions typically range from one to two months.
A *year* to get records? Especially at a time when food safety in Canada is under such scrutiny? Unacceptable.
Food inspection and safety in Canada needs a complete overhaul in order to gain back the public’s trust.